Monday, January 10, 2005

IndiBloggies nomination; and Year in Review

I've been nominated in three IndiBloggies categories. It's the Indian version of the more U.S. focused "Bloggies." If you're so inclined, you can vote for me.

Though I'm grateful to be nominated (thanks especially to Nitin) I must say I do feel these awards things are a little strange. I'm nominated in the same category as Om Malik, whose blog is a high-tech oriented, "industry" news-aggregator produced by a professional journalist, and Tsunami Help, which is less a blog than it is a massive news and information aggregator (they've gotten 1.5 million hits in about 10 days!). We are talking about comparing a professionalized apple (Om), a massive humanitarian orange (Tsunami), and in my own personal case, a very small, brainy grape.

Another problem: I hardly write exclusively about things related to India. I'm deeply interested in India, and I spent two weeks traveling around there this past summer, but I'm firmly attached to the soil (really, the pavement) of the I-95 corridor of the eastern United States. And my range of interests extends to all kinds of non-India-ish things. This is really a cross-category blog, not an "India blog," or an academic blog. (Then again, I am hardly alone in this.)

In lieu of begging for votes, this might be a good opportunity to review what in fact happened in 2004, which was a very busy year with regard to the Indian Subcontinent and its various diasporas. In addition to the Tsunami, there were historic elections and some major intellectual/academic controversies. There were some depressing anniversaries (Bhopal, Indira Gandhi's assasination, Operation Bluestar, communal violence against Sikhs). And there was Behzti. Here are some of what I consider to be the better more substantial posts related to Indian politics, literature, and film that I've written from the past year:

I enjoyed talking about Suketu Mehta's new book, Maximum City, which is probably the main "must read" book about India published in the U.S. this fall. I responded particularly to Mehta's point about naming and re-naming in "Bombay." Another promising young writer and critic whose work I praised in this blog is Amitava Kumar.

I closely followed the Behzti controversy, involving the Sikh community in England. I even posted a short story I wrote, inspired by the events. On Sikh issues, I also posted a consideration of the 20th anniversay of Operation Bluestar.

I provided short reviews of Amitav Ghosh's The Hungry Tide and Hari Kunzru's Transmission.

My post on Agha Shahid Ali tried to take an original approach to this sometimes neglected figure.

I've been following the ongoing trials and tribulations of Indian secularism, including the debates on Triple Talaq, and the half-hearted reforms of the All-India Muslim Personal Law Board. I've also provided some background on communalism.

I've been following the implementation of the Hijab and Turban ban in France, and have posted my critique.

I've talked about a couple of big controversies this past year in the Indian intellectual scene. One is the controversy surrounding Hinduism Studies in the U.S., especially the vehement attack on Wendy Doniger instigated by Rajiv Malhotra. See parts 1 and 2. I've also responded to the controversy around V.S. Naipaul's support for the Hindu right, which is seemingly out of keeping with his historical self-identification as an atheist and a rootless cosmopolitan.

I followed the upheaval of the Indian elections back in May, and wrote detailed profiles of Manmohan Singh as well as President Abdul Kalam.

On a lighter (but not that much lighter) note, I've written about my experiences DJing Bhangra parties, here, here, and here.

And amongst my reviews of Hindi films, I put a fair amount of thought into my review of Yuva, which I think is an extraordinary film by India's best commercial filmmaker.

All in all, a very busy year in Indian subcontinent happenings, and also, therefore, in India-related postings on this blog.

Thanks to everyone out there for reading, linking to me, and commenting.


sepoy said...

I agree that Shahid Ali deserves much wider recognitions. I have always admired his poetry (though I nitpick on his Faiz translations) and I include them in my south asian lit review section.

Loretta said...

Yo, just voted for you for 4 categories. You dah Indieblog man.

PhDiva said...

Congrats!! This is very exciting. All this time i thought i was just one of ew, not many, who think you are great. Keep it up!

Indiblogger said...

The Indibloggies is meant for Indian citizens as well as people of Indian origin. Categorizing a blog is often difficult given the fact that most of write on variety of topics at times. While you yourself admitted that yours is a Humanity blog many jurors may differ. Also for the Indiblog of the Year category all blogs, irrespective of their classification can compete.

Amardeep said...

Loretta: Thanks! BTW Where is your blog? You are the only law-student in New York City who doesn't have one!

Ph.Diva: Thanks also.

Indiblogger, sorry if I sounded like I was complaining. All I was trying to say was, I'm not sure how someone would objectively decide between such disparate blogs. But then maybe I'm taking the whole thing a little too seriously. Thanks for all the work you're doing.

Side thought: the Indian blogosphere really exploded this year, didn't it?

Loretta said...

No blogging for this kid! Hah hah! Got nothin to blog about! You know me! I just study a lot and go to the gym! I will send you an email.